The Hype Around Communities
We all talk about communities. Starbucks has one. LEGO has one. Harley-Davidson has one. On paper, having a community looks like the holy grail of marketing. Loyal fans connecting with each other. Endless user-generated content. A built-in engine for brand growth.
But here is the reality. Most brands are not ready for that. Either they do not have the resources to nurture a true community, or they are simply not in a stage where community should be a top priority. For early-stage brands, survival and growth come before belonging.
Think about the last time you interacted with a brand you had never heard of. Maybe they asked you to sign up for a rewards program right away. You could smell the marketing objectives from a mile away. Consumers today are savvy. They know when a brand is trying to lock them into a system that exists to drive sales. The result is predictable. People either ignore it completely, or they engage just enough to get a discount code or a freebie.
The Difference Between a Program and a Community
So if most brands cannot build a true community from the start, the real question becomes: how do you know when you are ready?
A rewards program is not the same as a community. Communities work when people actually want to engage with each other and with the brand itself. The glue is belonging. It is the sense that you are part of something bigger than yourself.
That is why Harley riders proudly tattoo the logo on their arms. That is why LEGO fans spend weeks designing new sets and rally others to vote for them. It is not just about the product. It is about identity, shared values, and collective creativity. It’s unrealistic to think that a brand can “brand” these things.
For a new brand, this is also nearly impossible to build from day one. You cannot fake belonging. You cannot bribe your way into loyalty.
Do You Actually Need One Right Now?
Not every brand is ready to build a community, and that is completely fine. A good sign you should hold off is if your product is still in the early stage, without clear repeat-purchase behavior or features that naturally bring people together. Another sign is when you do not yet have a few customers who champion your product without being asked. Communities thrive on volunteer energy, and if that is not there, forcing it will feel artificial.
You might also not be ready if your team cannot consistently create content or dedicate real time to nurturing conversations. Communities take steady attention, not spare hours squeezed in between other tasks. Finally, if you have not clarified a purpose that extends beyond your product, something people actually want to connect around, then you risk building an empty space.
What to Do Instead
If building your own branded community is out of reach for now, what is the alternative? The smarter starting point is to contribute to communities that already exist.
I have drawn inspiration from the art products industry. It is a field with many players, from small supply shops to big manufacturers, yet most do not try to build isolated branded communities. Instead, they contribute to the larger creative and artist community. By doing so, they earn trust, get noticed, and put real value out for others to benefit from.
Another example is a local food truck. Instead of launching its own “exclusive foodie club,” it might first participate in existing food festivals, neighborhood markets, or online groups for local dining. By showing up where people already gather, the truck can build recognition, share knowledge (like recipes or cooking tips), and add value to the local food culture before ever trying to launch its own branded loyalty program.
Three Phased Plays
The first phase is simply to participate. Show up in the places where your audience already spends time (online forums, local groups, or industry events) and focus on being useful. That might mean sharing tutorials, telling stories, or spotlighting members of the community.
Once you have built some trust, you can begin to host micro-moments. These are small, low-stakes activities like casual Q&As, mini-challenges, or live demos. They are not about pushing your product but about giving people a reason to connect around shared interests.
Only after you have built familiarity should you create your own home. This might be a forum, Discord, or dedicated social channel. Seed it with starter content and invite your most engaged members to help shape the culture.
Why This Works
By contributing first, you build credibility without the heavy lift of launching a branded community from scratch. You reduce the risk of forcing people into something they do not yet care about, while still building visibility and trust. Over time, as people see your consistent presence and the value you bring, they will naturally start to see your brand as something worth rallying around.
Closing Thought
Communities are powerful, but they are not where most brands should begin. If you are early stage, you do not need to build a community yet. What you do need is to show up where people already gather, contribute something useful, and prove that you belong in the conversation.
Focus on being present, authentic, and consistent in the larger spaces your customers care about. Share knowledge, amplify others, and solve real problems. If you do this over time, the foundation of your own community will take shape on its own.
Remember this: you do not build a community because you want one. You build trust until people want one with you.